Welcome to Maguire Toyota

Ithaca, NY

I know what I want.

New Arrivals

  • 2017 Toyota Sienna XLE 7 Passenger Van

    2017 Toyota Sienna XLE 7 Passenger Van

    • $39,974
    View Details
  • 2018 Toyota Highlander XLE V6 SUV

    2018 Toyota Highlander XLE V6 SUV

    • $41,668
    View Details
  • 2018 Toyota Highlander XLE V6 SUV

    2018 Toyota Highlander XLE V6 SUV

    • $42,063
    View Details
  • 2018 Toyota Corolla LE Sedan

    2018 Toyota Corolla LE Sedan

    • $20,158
    View Details
  • 2018 Toyota Corolla SE Sedan

    2018 Toyota Corolla SE Sedan

    • $23,147
    View Details

Welcome to Maguire Toyota

Are you ready to experience that "new car smell?" Does one of our pre-owned inventory strike the perfect chord? At Maguire Toyota in Ithaca, NY we're excited to put you in the driver's seat. Allow us to demonstrate our commitment to exceptional customer service!  Maguire Toyota in Ithaca, NY treats the needs of each individual customer with paramount concern. We know that you have high expectations, and as a car dealer we enjoy the challenge of meeting and exceeding those standards each and every time. Allow us to demonstrate how doing business with Maguire's is different. 

With the Maguire Family Commitment you will deal with Non-Commission Sales Consultants, you get the Maguire Family Price Guarantee, a Lifetime Engine Warranty, the Maguire Family Assurance, the Family Promise to Exceed All Your Expectations, a Three Day Money and Three Day Re-Finance Guarantee, a Trade Purchase Offer, and a 30 Day Used Vehicle Exchange.  If you live in Ithaca, Cortland, Elmira, Horseheads, Binghamton, Auburn, Vestal, Endicott, Johnson City, or anywhere in Upstate New York you will discover why purchasing a New
or Pre-owned vehicle from Maguire's is different. At Maguire's you will find Value exceeds the Price on every New and Pre-owned vehicle.

Maguire Toyota's Experienced Non-Commission Sales Staff is eager to share their Knowledge and Enthusiasm with you. We encourage you to browse our online inventory, schedule a test drive and investigate financing options or see if you qualify for the Maguire Instant Approval. You can also request more information about a vehicle using our online form or by calling (607) 257-1515!

Browse our new and pre-owned inventories, and don't forget to view our latest specials and promotions. If you can't find your dream vehicle, simply complete the CarFinder form and we'll begin the search for you! Better yet, you'll automatically be notified when matching inventory arrives.  Dealership: Directions for step-by-step driving instructions to our site, or give us a call. We look forward to serving you!